I Know Why Refractive Surgeons Wear Glasses
Refractive Surgery's Effects on Retinal Image and Contrast Sensitivity
mail.gif
EyeKnowWhy - Zone Effects Page Updated: 9/14/97 Scroll as we Load!Bugs?
Questions?
Comments?

RK Eye Icon Use Your Back Key or Click Here to Return to Home Page PRK Eye Icon

Update Status: THIS IS A NEW PAGE AND IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION. Site contents subject to change.

Refractive Surgery's Effects on Retina Image and Contrast Sensitivity

Defining Contrast Sensitivity
Diagram Explanations

The following diagram (Figure A) is the working diagram for all explanations within this page.

In Figure A, the eye's optical 'mechanics' have been broken down into the following xx sections:

  • Cornea - The cornea is shown enlarged, and the various layers (Epithelium, Bowman's, Stroma, Descemet's Membrane and Endothelium) are color coded.
  • Iris - The iris opens and closes to control the amount of light entering the inner eye. The aqueuous humor that separates the cornea and the iris is not shown.
  • Lens - The lens is shown in Figure A in it's relaxed state. This is the assumed state for most figures in this page. It is assumed to be 'clear' and does not distort light.
  • Retina - The retina is shown as a curved 'panel' that the image is displayed upon. This is highly simplified since the retina is extremely complex consisting of rods, cones, optic nerve network, etc., but will do for these illustrations.

WORK SECTION - Topics to be Included:

The following table, PRK/LASIK Tissue Ablation Depths, provides estimates ot the depth of ablation for various refractive correction attempts. Ablation Depth is for the central part of the cornea, and decreases as you 'move out' to the transtion edge. Larger refractive errors require greater depth and longer laser exposure times. Likewise, wound response and haze are directly related to ablation depth and transition edges must be steeper for greater ablations, thus causing greater 'central haze' and 'ring haze' effect. These numbers are approximate only. The total cornea thickness varies between 450 and 650 microns, and tends to be thinnest at the center.

PRK/LASIK Tissue Ablation Depths
Refractive Error
Correction Attempted
Ablation
Depth
(6mm/7mm)
Ablation Zone
Refractive Error
Correction Attempted
Ablation
Depth
(6mm/7mm)
Ablation Zone
-2.0 24/33 microns >-3.0 36/49 microns
-4.0 48/66 microns -5.0 60/82 microns
-6.0 72/98 microns -7.0 84/115 microns
-8.0 96/131 microns -9.0 108/147 microns
-10.0 120/162 microns -11.0 132/178 microns
-12.0 144/193 microns -13.0 156/209 microns
-14.0 168/225 microns -15.0 180/240 microns

Observations:

  • The amount of tissue removed increases greatly as you move up the refractive error curve. A LASIK ablation procedure begins approximately 160 microns (1/3) into the stroma (the cap is usually 160 microns or thicker). Thus a person having a 12D correction would actually have an 'effective' ablation depth of 304 microns (160 flap depth + 144 ablation depth) using a 6mm ablation zone. That's pretty deep, and you are getting close to the endothelium (within 200 microns) with the final laser pulses. This also presents the issue of cornea stability; i.e., just how much tissue removal can the cornea tolerate before ecstasia (instability, tissue breakdown) occurs?
  • As the ablation depth increases, the transition to the unablated area must be steeper.
  • Wider ablation zones (7mm) requires greater ablation depth.

You need to understand ablation depths since they impact night vision, contrast sensitivity and light scatter when the pupil is dilated.

Topics to Discuss:
Small retina image daytime/large retina image lowlight, rods and cones (locations, functions in the retina)
cell alignment and scatter, indirect (reflected) and direct light rays, photons, and EyeKnowWhy's theory of glare effects after refractive surgery.
Refractive projections (before surgery w & w/o glass/contact correction)
Limitations on optimum focus of large zone incoming light ray image in upoperated eyes and the added complexity of normal regular astigmatism; spherical vs aspherical cornea discussion
Refractive projections (after surgery w & w/o glass/contact correction)
Astigmaism (regular, irregular, against the rule)
What is contrast sensitivity?
What is night driving vision?
What is multifocal lens effect (ghosting, double vision)?
How zones (central, transition, untouched) effect retina image

DIAGRAMS (numerous)
General Diagrams w/Explanation: simple 2dim diagrams, explain light rays to discuss refaction/vision 'sharpness' as pupil dilates Diagram: Optical zones, day,night Diagrams: Retina, fovea, cones,rods,optic nerve, blind spot, disc:sharp central vision, low light vision, blind spot, macula/fovea
Diagram(s): cornea,pupil,lens,retina - normal eye sight;no correction (day diagram - light ray -daytime refraction to points on retina, night diagram -night refraction to points on retina)
Repeat of above diagrams for near and far sightedness, astigmatism (limits on astig. disc. - regular, irregular, correction, references)
Diagrams (correcting near/far/astig in unoperated eyes): cornea,pupil,lens,retina - day and nighttime lightrays
Diagram - RK change in cornea structure (3mm 'clear' optical zone),scar scatter, distorted mid and peripheral zones, how this occurs, correcting errors after RK, day and nighttime
Diagram - PRK change in cornea structure (6mm zone, 4mm optimum focus,1mm each side transition, untouched outside 6mm), correcting errors after PRK, day and nighttime Diagram - LASIK, similar to PRK (may not do, just use PRK w/notes)
Astigmatic Surgery/Farsighted Surgery - depends, may do or annotate other diagrams.

Post-operative Contact Lens To Reduce Zone Transition Effects


Contact lens fitting may be a problem after refractive surgery since the wound profile does not 'fit' any standard contact design. Because the ablation wound tends to be a little bit off center, and the scarred wound edge rough, contacts tend to 'ride up' into the top of the eye, or pop out. They also tend to get 'bubble' pools of tears under them where the 'crater-shaped' wound is. In the case of RK, the worped cornea and elevated scars make contact lens wear nearly impossible. At least one contact lens vendor is now marketing contacts with 'flat' interiors to improve fit over post-operative corneas.

Patients who have had RK should not wear contacts; it is the worse thing they can do. They don't fit at all, they irritate, and they cause serious complications like ulcers, infections, and accelerated vascularization emanating around the scars and peripheral cornea where it merges into the sclera. What's more, they accelerate endothelial cell loss, which can lead to serious cornea edema and ulceration.

Even so, some post PRK patients and some RK patients do try to wear contacts after surgery. Current studies of contact lens wear fitting are short term, following patients who have been fitted for only a few weeks or months. Long term studies of contact lens wear and their success or failure will be documented in the CLAO journal.

Contacts tend to reduce irregular astimatism's effects, especially on night vision and reduce the effect of GASH. This is possible since the contact lens provides a 'new' cornea surface effectively eliminating the transition zone. But there are limitations. The light rays must still pass through the altered cornea tissue which can induce scattering and some residual irregular astigmatism.

Diagram(s) : Fitting Contact Lens after Surgery, how it causes cavitation bubbles or rides up and how it reduces scatter and multifocal effect.

Fitting Glasses After Surgery For Optimum Night Vision


Fitting glasses after refractive surgery is somewhat more difficult in many cases dependent on the patient's preoperative prescription and the results of surgery.


For people who have mild to moderate myopia, good refractive symmetry and small amounts of astigmatism, they may be surprised that the eyeglasses they require after surgery may have mild spherical corrections but unusual astigmatic cylinder corrections and greater difference in spherical diopters between the two eyes. Of course, people who had high myopia, severe astigmaatism, and signficant anisometropia prior to surgery may have 'more normal' prescriptions after surgery.

Everyone should be aware that increased GASH and irregular astigmatism cannot be eliminated by eyeglasses. Fitting eyeglasses for optimal night vision is a hit and miss procedure, at least in theory. In diagram x, a corrective lens is placed in front of the altered cornea surface to change the focus of light rays at night. As can be seen in this diagram.....(see diagrams above)





If you have any questions or comments, please contact eyeknowwhy@aol.com.


PRK Eye Icon
To Top of Page (or Use Browser Top of Page Key)PRK Eye Icon